The Polite Muzzle

How Free Speech Wasn’t Taken… It Was Tidied Away

Somewhere between “be kind” and “for your safety”, we misplaced something important.

Not lost it dramatically. No bonfires of books. No jackboots kicking down doors. Nothing so theatrical. That would have required attention… resistance… a spine.

No, free speech didn’t vanish in a blaze of tyranny. It was quietly reorganised. Tidied. Labelled. Wrapped in soft language and filed under Approved Opinions (Version 6.4).

Much neater that way.

Thanks for reading Unharnessed! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

The modern gag isn’t forced silence. It’s conditional permission.

You may speak…
But only if your words are “responsible”.
You may question…
But only if it’s phrased gently enough to not disturb the furniture.
You may dissent…
But only after acknowledging the approved premise, the correct emotional framing, and the moral authority of whoever wrote the rules this week.

Say the wrong thing and nobody arrests you. That would look bad. Instead, you’re de-ranked. Shadowed. Throttled. Nudged gently into irrelevance by systems that insist they’re neutral while doing an excellent impression of a hall monitor with a clipboard.

And the truly clever part… most people cheer it on.

They call it progress. Safety. Decency. “Just basic standards.”

Funny how those standards always seem to move… and always in one direction.

What we’re living through isn’t censorship in the old sense. It’s pre-emptive obedience. People editing their thoughts before they’ve even finished thinking them. Pausing mid-sentence, not because they’re wrong, but because they’re tired. Tired of explaining. Tired of being misread. Tired of being told that intent no longer matters, only impact… as defined by the most offended person in the room.

So they shrink their language. Sand down their edges. Replace honesty with something safer. Beige. Algorithm-friendly.

A civilisation whispering to itself in case it says something naughty.

The great irony… free speech was never meant to be comfortable. It was meant to be alive. Messy. Occasionally offensive. Frequently inconvenient. The price of hearing the truth is tolerating ideas you don’t like. That used to be understood. Now it’s treated like a design flaw.

We’re told speech must be managed because words are dangerous. That they cause harm. That people can’t be trusted with open discourse.

And yet… the same institutions telling us this are perfectly happy to centralise power, automate decisions, and govern millions with systems nobody elected and few understand.

Apparently, words are the threat. Not control.

The result is a population that doesn’t need to be silenced. It does the job itself. People are scanning every sentence for compliance. Checking the emotional weather before speaking honestly. Asking, Is this allowed? Will this cost me something?

That isn’t maturity. It’s fear dressed up as politeness.

And here’s the part nobody likes to admit out loud…
Many people prefer it this way.

Because free speech demands something awkward. Courage. Accountability. The willingness to be disliked. The acceptance that you might be wrong and still deserve to speak. That someone else might be wrong and still deserve to be heard.

That’s hard work.

Much easier to outsource thinking to the crowd, morality to the algorithm, and courage to a future version of yourself that never quite arrives.

But a society that cannot speak freely cannot think freely. And a society that cannot think freely doesn’t stay free for long… it just stays quiet.

The muzzle isn’t metal. It’s velvet. Soft enough that people forget it’s there. Comfortable enough that they defend it. “It’s not stopping me speaking,” they say, while carefully not saying anything that might matter.

So this is your gentle, impolite reminder.

If you feel yourself hesitating before telling the truth… pause and ask why.
If you feel your language shrinking… ask who benefits.
If you feel relieved that someone else is being silenced instead of you… understand that the line is simply moving closer.

Free speech isn’t protected by laws alone. It’s protected by people who use it.

Not perfectly. Not politely. Not safely.

But honestly.

Thanks for reading Unharnessed.
Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

With warmth, clarity… and a refusal to whisper.
Dominus Owen Markham